Firm Energy Options for the Last 10%-20%
Project #9

Why Molokai needs 10-20% firm energy for reliable electric power, at least with current technologies. HNEI’s PIE modeling tool illustrates the rise and fall of energy demand (black line) throughout a typical week on Molokai and how solar energy (yellow and light orange) and batteries (dark orange) serve that demand. During a sunny week (shown in the top chart), each day creates more solar energy than needed. Some of that extra solar energy is captured in batteries (dark blue) for use at night, but once the batteries are full, the rest of the extra solar energy is wasted or “curtailed” (red). During a rainy or overcast week (shown in the bottom chart), there is not enough extra sunlight during the day to fully charge the batteries. That means at night, the grid must rely on a FIRM ENERGY option to meet customer electricity use – in this model it is a diesel generator (gray).
Firm energy sources are available at all times, controllable and reliable. Like a generator, it will provide energy whenever it is turned on. Solar panels and wind turbines are not considered ‘firm energy sources’ because the energy you get is completely dependent on the weather. Renewable firm energy can come from bioenergy, hydroelectric energy, and geothermal energy. Firm energy is needed to ensure that the electric grid is always supplied – rain or shine. Over-building solar (and/or wind) and batteries to cover spells of bad weather can be extremely expensive. Firm energy is essential to fill in these rare gaps, when needed most.
