Firm Energy Options for the Last 10%-20%

Project #9

Why Molokai needs 10-20% firm energy for reliable electric power, at least with current technologies. HNEI’s PIE modeling tool illustrates the rise and fall of energy demand (black line) throughout a typical week on Molokai and how solar energy (yellow and light orange) and batteries (dark orange) serve that demand. During a sunny week (shown in the top chart), each day creates more solar energy than needed. Some of that extra solar energy is captured in batteries (dark blue) for use at night, but once the batteries are full, the rest of the extra solar energy is wasted or “curtailed” (red). During a rainy or overcast week (shown in the bottom chart), there is not enough extra sunlight during the day to fully charge the batteries. That means at night, the grid must rely on a FIRM ENERGY option to meet customer electricity use – in this model it is a diesel generator (gray).

Firm energy sources are available at all times, controllable and reliable. Like a generator, it will provide energy whenever it is turned on. Solar panels and wind turbines are not considered ‘firm energy sources’ because the energy you get is completely dependent on the weather. Renewable firm energy can come from bioenergy, hydroelectric energy, and geothermal energy. Firm energy is needed to ensure that the electric grid is always supplied – rain or shine. Over-building solar (and/or wind) and batteries to cover spells of bad weather can be extremely expensive. Firm energy is essential to fill in these rare gaps, when needed most.

  • Onsite generation decreases the risk of electric disruption for critical infrastructure and takes into account sea level rise/road flooding/etc. that could isolate certain areas for long periods of time.

Firm energy sources are available at all times, controllable and reliable. Like a generator, it will provide energy whenever it is turned on. Solar panels and wind turbines are not considered ‘firm energy sources’ because the energy you get is completely dependent on the weather. Renewable firm energy can come from bioenergy, hydroelectric energy, and geothermal energy. Firm energy is needed to ensure that the electric grid is always supplied – rain or shine. Over-building solar (and/or wind) and batteries to cover spells of bad weather can be extremely expensive. Firm energy is essential to fill in these rare gaps, when needed most.

Strengths

😊

  • Dispatchable energy available whenever you need it (e.g. can turn up a generator if no sun or wind).
  • Required for a stable grid and reliable electricity service.

😣

Weaknesses

  • Currently provided by diesel, which does not meet the State’s goal of 100% RE by 2045.
  • It is not clear how diesel generators at Pālāʻau will be decommissioned or transitioned to clean alternatives.

Opportunities

😍

  • Projects could provide grid services for the larger Molokai grid and support future smart grid innovations.
  • Can design Molokai regional systems to support mobile emergency generators and additional cold storage units (for food and mass casualties) that strengthen emergency response and disaster preparedness facilities.
  • Smart meters provide detailed insight on how RE is performing and how much energy is being used/generated to help energy operators protect the grid and homes.
  • Hui Up style programs could be a solution for supporting privately-owned critical infrastructure in equipping their facilities with RE systems.
  • Currently provided by diesel, which does not meet the State’s goal of 100% RE by 2045.
  • It is not clear how diesel generators at Pālāʻau will be decommissioned or transitioned to clean alternatives.

😱

Threats

  • “Hosting capacity” for rooftop PV is very limited. Therefore, new onsite RE would likely need to be paired with batteries and energy exporting options may or may not be available.
  • Adequate supply.
  • Non-fossil fuel alternatives are likely to be costly.
  • Uncertain if firm energy fuel must be imported or can be produced locally

The Molokai community is in FULL SUPPORT of and committed to co-designing a site specific community-scale solar project for Maunaloa/West Molokai that provides the level
of energy quality, stability, resilience, and economic relief the Maunaloa community needs.

  • Community-based site specific project design that provides a detailed cost analysis and understanding of trade-offs between potential project sites and critical infrastructure location, tech options, community needs, potential grid services and configurations (e.g. islandable or hybrid microgrid), responsible end of life plans, environmental and cultural impacts and the other energy system requirements described earlier.
  • Maunaloa/West Molokai’s RE project must account for current community needs, future growth, grid hardening, and the potential diversification of energy generation for West Molokai.
  • The Molokai community, and especially those who live in Maunaloa/West Molokai, will have the final say on how RE projects like this can support them individually and as a community.
  • Disallow HECO self-build from competing in potential project RPF; thereby promoting competitive bidding.

No comments yet

Have mana‘o about this project? Please share it with us